I have to say that when asking for advice on anything, "woulda coulda shoulda" are my LEAST favourite words.
I thought I had mentioned earlier that any new bird should be quarantined
so as to give you time to watch it and make sure it is healthy. But you had said that they came together. If I didn't then I'm sorry that I didn't mention that. I should have, but can't think of everything. This thread isn't the only thing I have in my day.
I mentioned on this board several days ago, that I was thinking of buying a hen to keep my male company, BEFORE I went out and bought one. I mentioned that my reasoning for getting a hen was that I was worried about the male being alone and pining away for another bird, and that I was concerned that it would be cruel to keep him alone. Was I told not to get a hen? No, the verbatim response was: "He would be much happier with a mate than without.
Why would we tell you not to get a hen?
Yes, we told you that a pigeon spending his life alone in a cage without another pigeon would not be a happy existence for him. That doesn't mean that he has to have one right away. You seemed to want to get one right away. You could have taken your time and it would have been fine. Wouldn't think that would have had to have been said.
When you do get one, don't put her into his cage. They need to get used to each other from separate cages that are beside each other."
Was I told I didn't need to get a hen right away? Was I told it wouldn't be cruel for the male to be alone for a few weeks? NOPE. So guess what - I went ahead and bought a hen. Now I'm being lambasted for it?
I would think it would be common sense that he didn't need a mate for a few weeks. I mean come on, some things are common sense. We cannot tell you every single step to take. And we have not lambasted you for it.
And remember the quote above about the separate cages next to each other? I replied to that, stating I don't have separate cages but that I'd be building a barrier in the cage instead. Was I told this wouldn't be sufficient for quarantine? Well, I woulda coulda shoulda been told, but - not a word about quarantine. Now the birds are exposed to each other. I'm being slammed for keeping the birds in the same room, much less the same cage, because the hen needs to be quarantined in a separate room for weeks. Once again, I wasn't told this BEFORE I brought the hen home. Now I'm being told that I have to uproot three birds that are just starting to get used to their new homes, and swap them around between cages so the two males are in the same cage again and the hen can sit by herself in a tiny cage, to be quarantined from a bird she's already been exposed to for several days. I'm being told that I have to split the hen from the male, when they're starting to get along, and cooing back and forth at each other.
I don't see how you are being slammed for keeping them in the same room. I don't see where you have been slammed or lambasted.
The only thing we may have forgotten to bring up is that they should be quarantined for a while. Sorry if that wasn't explained to you. I thought I had mentioned it earlier on. If I didn't, then I should have, but again, we all have lives too, with a lot going on, and sometimes may forget to say something.
Yet, I was told, when I was about to buy a different hen, that if she's bonded to another male it would be cruel for me to split them up, so I gave up the hen that I wanted (not that I don't like the one I have) because she was paired. Now I'm being told to split this hen that I have from the male she's getting used to...
If you are that upset over separating her for a few weeks, then don't. Maybe she is healthy and all will be fine. The quarantine is probably the only thing we didn't think of. We do normally suggest that to people. But like I said, we all have lives with lots going on, and things can be overlooked. I think everything else you needed to know has been pretty much covered.
The problem with "woulda coulda shoulda" (also known as second-guessing) is that it denigrates people for doing, or not doing, something that's now in the past and beyond their control - unless I take the hen back to the breeder, I guess. That's not acceptable to me. Hindsight is always 20/20 - but it doesn't help anything, it's just insulting and patronizing.
I don't even know why you feel that the hen should be brought back to the breeder. Is that easier than separating her for a few weeks?
Please understand that I do appreciate the helpful advice - but second guessing and finding fault with everything I do is very frustrating, confusing and makes me feel like I can't do anything right.
What is it that we have found fault with? We didn't think about quarantine as this thread has been changing so much that you lose track. Easy to overlook something. One thing. Well you know what, right now I have too much on my plate to argue with someone on P.T. about how they keep their birds, so enjoy them and keep them however you want to. I'm sure you'll learn as you go and do a good job. I have only been trying to help, but I don't need more stress here.